Score: 7

"Sounds like a castle!"

submission: The Black Castle

date: October 15, 2009

Nice job with the percussion! While the melody could use a little work I still get a good feel for a dark castle when listening to this, so the style is still pretty good.

Score: 8

"One of your better works!"

submission: Through New Eyes

date: September 28, 2009

Sounds like the kind of music you listen to at the first town in an RPG, like at home or walking around town. Anyway, the only thing you might want to take a look at the bass way in the background. Make it something you can hum, it doesn't really sound like it's in tune. Not sure if that's how it's supposed to sound, but I think it would sound better that way.

Score: 8

"Very interesting!!"

submission: The Demon Slayer

date: September 27, 2009

It's very creepy, the title suits it well! The panning is a bit strange at one part but other than that I like the feel of this one!

Score: 6

"Don't make it metal just yet!"

submission: The Half-Angel Freak (Revised)

date: September 27, 2009

If you ask me this piece could be a lot better if you slow it down a bit, and use different velocities for the strings (so it's not so loud all the time). Also change the bass, it sounds like it's in a different key signature which can cause a lot of dissonance. This could be a great instrumental piece if you work on your harmony!

Score: 7

"Watch the pitch"

submission: With Blessing (Bell's Theme)

date: September 27, 2009

I'm not sure if it's the particular instrument but it gets a bit messy when those higher notes are hit. Might want to lower it an octave or try a different type of bell. But this is very original, and that's what Iike about it! The only other thing that could use some work is the end, it's a little strange to me.

Score: 6

"Interesting interpretation"

submission: Fighting of the Spirit ToS rmx

date: September 27, 2009

There's a lot of dissonance going on in the background, I think it may be your instrument choice. I suggest you rework some of the harmonies going on here. Sorry if this rating is a bit harsh, but don't forget I remixed this song as well! I really like the first few seconds of this piece though, that earned you an extra point!

Score: 8

"Nice and light"

submission: Hyrule Temple Orchestral

date: September 27, 2009

Not particularly intense, but I like the feel of it. Especially what you did with the timpanis, it sounds very cinematic. It's no Smashing Live, but still good nonetheless!

Score: 8

"Easy listening!"

submission: Piano "Adlib" ep 2, Nathan rmx

date: August 24, 2009

Here's my review (thanks for reviewing mine!)

Very relaxing mood, it would make great background music for a casual conversation in restaurant or something in a motion picture. Kind of makes me think of those Detective pictures where they're saying their monologues and such the whole movie.

Anyway, personally this is not my favorite style of music, but I can appreciate good work nonetheless! The only cons I have are that it's a bit repetitive, but it loops VERY well so I guess I can't complain since it's over a minute and all.